University of Minnesota
University of Minnesota
College of Biological Sciences
http://www.cbs.umn.edu/

All Methods

Log Out

Methods for Experiment 001 -

Field Operations: Burning

Plots in field D were burned in 1981, 1982, 1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1996, 1997, 1999, 2000, 2002, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2008, and 2009, 2011, 2012, 2014

Plots in fields A, B, and C were burned in 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014

Field Operations: Fencing

The plots in experiment E001 are enclosed by a fence to exclude mammalian herbivores. Galvanized welded-wire hardware cloth with 6mm x 6mm openings was buried to a depth of 84cm. Additional hardware cloth extends 60cm above the ground, and poultry netting extends to 1.8m above the ground. During the summer of 1986, aluminum flashing was placed in the ground to a depth of 12 inches. This flashing surrounds each plot in each field, keeping the plants from spreading between plots by below-ground vegetative reproduction. The aluminum flashing is placed 12 inches from the edge of each plot. In fall 2004, herbivore exclosure fences were removed from fields A, B, and D, and from all plots in field C except the following: 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 25, 26, 29, 30, 31, 32, 37, 46, 47, 48, 50, 51, 52, and 53.

Field Operations: Fertilization

Fertilizer is mixed and spread by hand twice a year, once in early May and once in late June. Each plot gets the fertilizer mixture specified by its fertilizer treatment code.

Layout of Plots

Plots for this experiment are 4x4 meter squares in fields A, B, and C and 1.5x4 meters in Field D. One meter walkways separate the plots. In the table the plot number is followed by the treatment code.

Field A
54-A 53-A 52-H 51-F 50-A 49-E
48-G 47-I 46-I 45-A 44-G 43-B
42-F 41-D 40-H 39-F 38-D 37-C
36-G 35-B 34-G 33-I 32-E 31-E
30-C 29-C 28-E 27-C 26-B 25-G
24-D 23-D 22-A 21-F 20-I 19-E
18-H 17-H 16-B 15-C 14-F 13-E
12-A 11-H 10-C 09-F 08-D 07-G
06-H 05-I 04-B 03-D 02-B 01-I
Field B
54-A 53-G 52-I 5l-F 50-G 49-B
48-C 47-H 46-E 45-E 44-H 43-C
42-G 41-D 40-B 39-H 38-D 37-I
36-D 35-I 34-A 33-A 32-F 31-B
30-E 29-F 28-C 27-E 26-B 25-C
24-D 23-C 22-H 2l-I 20-C 19-F
18-G 17-A 16-F 15-G 14-D 13-B
12-I 11-A 10-B 09-E 08-G 07-F
06-I 05-E 04-H 03-H 02-D 01-A
Field C
54-I 53-I 52-F 51-H 50-D 49-E
48-G 47-A 46-D 45-D 44-H 43-A
42-B 41-A 40-G 39-A 38-E 37-B
36-C 35-E 34-C 33-I 32-C 31-F
30-I 29-H 28-I 27-B 26-A 25-G
24-F 23-H 22-G 21-H 20-C 19-D
18-I 17-B 16-E 15-H 14-E 13-F
12-G 11-B 10-D 09-F 08-A 07-C
06-E 05-D 04-B 03-G 02-C 01-F
Field D
45-G 44-I 43-B
42-B 41-E 40-F
39-A 38-A SKIP
37-D 36-A 35-C
34-I 33-I 32-H
31-B SKIP 30-G
SKIP 29-D 28-G
27-H 26-E 25-I
SKIP 24-C 23-F
SKIP 22-D 21-E
SKIP 20-H 19-E
18-F 17-A 16-F
15-F* 14-D 13-G
12-B 11-C 10-D
09-H 08-H 07-C
06-C 05-E 04-B
03-G 02-I 01-A
 

* 15 was originally mislabeled as G

Microplot Fertilization Treatments

The "microplot" fertilization treatments are used in experiments 1, 2, 4, 8, 9, 11, 23, 25, and 52. Experiments 5, 6, 28, 36,53,97, 98 and 100 are conducted within plots that are fertilized and should be treated as part of the fertilized plot. There are nine treatment levels, assigned a letter A through I. This is also equivalent to the numeric labels 1 to 9. Treatment levels A through H differ in the amount of NH4NO3 added. Treatment I is a true control and receives no nutrients. The nutrients are applied twice a year, once in early May and once in late June. An exception is experiment 25 where time of application is experimentally manipulated. Not all experiments use all possible treatments. Nutrients are given in g/m2 for each fertilization; plot area and treatments used follow the nutrient lists. Treatment A to H receive the following base nutrients:

RateVolumeElement
10 g/m2150 mlP2O5 (0-46-0)
10 g/m2150 mlK2O (0-0-61)
20 g/m2200 mlCaCO3 (lime)
15m2200 mlMgSO4 (Epsom Salts)
0.0625 ml/m2trace mineral solution in 1 ml to 10 ml sand
 

The description for making trace mineral sand is at the end of this section. The amount of NH4NO3 fertilizer added at the different treatment levels is:

TreatmentRateVolume
A0.0 g/m20 ml
B 1.5 g/m2 25 ml
C 3.0 g/m2 50 ml
D 5.0 g/m2 90 ml
E 8.0 g/m2 140 ml
F 14.0 g/m2 250 ml
G 25.0 g/m2 445 ml
H 40.0 g/m2 710 ml
I 0.0 g/m2 0 ml
 

These rates are added twice a year. Actual annual N addition is calculated as: 0.34%N * rate (g/m2) * 2 times/year The trace mineral stock solutions are made by adding the following grams of reagent to 1000 ml of water: CuSO4*5H2O 9.8 g ZnSO4*7H2O 22.0 g or ZnCl2 10.5 g CoCl2*6H2O 10.0 g MnCl2*4H2O 180.0 g Na2MoO4*2H2O 6.3 g H3BO3 6.0 g The trace metal solution is made by combining 120ml of each stock solution, adding 67.2g of citric acid dissolved in deionized water and adding deionized water to bring the volume to a total of 2 liters. The working solution is then autoclaved to chelate the trace metals. The size of the plots and treatments used for each experiment are:

ExperimentTreatmentsPlot size (m2)
Experiment 1 except Field DA thru I 16
Experiment 1 Field DA thru I 6
Experiment 2 A thru I 16
Experiment 4 E, G, I 1000
Experiment 8 C, F, H, I 16
Experiment 9 C, F, H, I16
Experiment 11 E, G, I16
Experiment 24 E, G, I16
Experiment 25 E, G, I5.25
Experiment 52A, C, F, G25
 

Microplot Fertilization Treatments

Some changes and/or additions occur from year to year for some experiments. These changes are listed below. Unless specific experiments are mentioned, these differences apply to all experiments in a category. In 1982, 30ml of each stock solution was combined with 16.8g citric acid, brought to a total volume of 1 liter, and autoclaved to dissolve. 1.5ml of this solution was added to 30ml of silica sand, mixed and dried. In 1983, 60ml of each stock solution was combined with 25g of EDTA brought to 1 liter, and autoclaved to dissolve. 1ml of this solution was added to 10ml of sand and added to each plot. In 1984, 60ml of each stock solution was combined with 25g of citric acid and brought to 1 liter. In 1985, the first fertilization for experiments 1 and 2, Treatment F received an extra 23 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment G received an extra 118.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment H received an extra 132.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 In 1985, between fertilizations for experiments 1 and 2, Treatment G received 137.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment H received 206.25 g/m2 of CaCO3 In 1985, the second fertilization for experiments 1 and 2, Treatment F received an extra 23.0 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment G received an extra 252.7 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment H received an extra 441.1 g/m2 of CaCO3 In 1985, the first fertilization for experiment 4, Treatment E received no CaCO3 Treatment G received an extra 45.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 In 1985, both fertilizations for experiments 8, 9, and 11, Treatment F received an extra 23 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment G received an extra 43.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 Treatment H received an extra 57.5 g/m2 of CaCO3 In 1989, lime was added to adjust pH to the following treatments in the spring: Quantities of lime stone (g/plot):

Experiment 1
TreatmentField AField BField CField D
A000200
B00320200
C0 0 320 200
D 850 320 320 200
E 1000 850 1000 200
F 1300 1200 1900 200
G 1300 320 320 200
H 2100 1600 1000 20
I 0 0 0 0
 

In the fall of 1989, each plot receiving treatments B, C, D, E, F, G and H in field D of experiment 1, received 1067g of lime to adjust pH.

Treatment layout

Nitrogen treatments 1 through 9 are the same as treatments A through I, respectively.

Field Identification Experiment Number Plot Number Nitrogen Treatment Ammonium Nitrate(34-0-0) addition(g/m2/yr)
A 1 1 9 0
A 1 2 2 3
A 1 3 4 10
A 1 4 2 3
A 1 5 9 0
A 1 6 8 80
A 1 7 7 50
A 1 8 4 10
A 1 9 6 28
A 1 10 3 6
A 1 11 8 80
A 1 12 1 0
A 1 13 5 16
A 1 14 6 28
A 1 15 3 6
A 1 16 2 3
A 1 17 8 80
A 1 18 8 80
A 1 19 5 16
A 1 20 9 0
A 1 21 6 28
A 1 22 1 0
A 1 23 4 10
A 1 24 4 10
A 1 25 7 50
A 1 26 2 3
A 1 27 3 6
A 1 28 5 16
A 1 29 3 6
A 1 30 3 6
A 1 31 5 16
A 1 32 5 16
A 1 33 9 0
A 1 34 7 50
A 1 35 2 3
A 1 36 7 50
A 1 37 3 6
A 1 38 4 10
A 1 39 6 28
A 1 40 8 80
A 1 41 4 10
A 1 42 6 28
A 1 43 2 3
A 1 44 7 50
A 1 45 1 0
A 1 46 9 0
A 1 47 9 0
A 1 48 7 50
A 1 49 5 16
A 1 50 1 0
A 1 51 6 28
A 1 52 8 80
A 1 53 1 0
A 1 54 1 0
B 1 1 1 0
B 1 2 4 10
B 1 3 8 80
B 1 4 8 80
B 1 5 5 16
B 1 6 9 0
B 1 7 6 28
B 1 8 7 50
B 1 9 5 16
B 1 10 2 3
B 1 11 1 0
B 1 12 9 0
B 1 13 2 3
B 1 14 4 10
B 1 15 7 50
B 1 16 6 28
B 1 17 1 0
B 1 18 7 50
B 1 19 6 28
B 1 20 3 6
B 1 21 9 0
B 1 22 8 80
B 1 23 3 6
B 1 24 4 10
B 1 25 3 6
B 1 26 2 3
B 1 27 5 16
B 1 28 3 6
B 1 29 6 28
B 1 30 5 16
B 1 31 2 3
B 1 32 6 28
B 1 33 1 0
B 1 34 1 0
B 1 35 9 0
B 1 36 4 10
B 1 37 9 0
B 1 38 4 10
B 1 39 8 80
B 1 40 2 3
B 1 41 4 10
B 1 42 7 50
B 1 43 3 6
B 1 44 8 80
B 1 45 5 16
B 1 46 5 16
B 1 47 8 80
B 1 48 3 6
B 1 49 2 3
B 1 50 7 50
B 1 51 6 28
B 1 52 9 0
B 1 53 7 50
B 1 54 1 0
C 1 1 6 28
C 1 2 3 6
C 1 3 7 50
C 1 4 2 3
C 1 5 4 10
C 1 6 5 16
C 1 7 3 6
C 1 8 1 0
C 1 9 6 28
C 1 10 4 10
C 1 11 2 3
C 1 12 7 50
C 1 13 6 28
C 1 14 5 16
C 1 15 8 80
C 1 16 5 16
C 1 17 2 3
C 1 18 9 0
C 1 19 4 10
C 1 20 3 6
C 1 21 8 80
C 1 22 7 50
C 1 23 8 80
C 1 24 6 28
C 1 25 7 50
C 1 26 1 0
C 1 27 2 3
C 1 28 9 0
C 1 29 8 80
C 1 30 9 0
C 1 31 6 28
C 1 32 3 6
C 1 33 9 0
C 1 34 3 6
C 1 35 5 16
C 1 36 3 6
C 1 37 2 3
C 1 38 5 16
C 1 39 1 0
C 1 40 7 50
C 1 41 1 0
C 1 42 2 3
C 1 43 1 0
C 1 44 8 80
C 1 45 4 10
C 1 46 4 10
C 1 47 1 0
C 1 48 7 50
C 1 49 5 16
C 1 50 4 10
C 1 51 8 80
C 1 52 6 28
C 1 53 9 0
C 1 54 9 0
D 1 1 1 0
D 1 2 9 0
D 1 3 7 50
D 1 4 2 3
D 1 5 5 16
D 1 6 3 6
D 1 7 3 6
D 1 8 8 80
D 1 9 8 80
D 1 10 4 10
D 1 11 3 6
D 1 12 2 3
D 1 13 7 50
D 1 14 4 10
D 1 15 6 28
D 1 16 6 28
D 1 17 1 0
D 1 18 6 28
D 1 19 5 16
D 1 20 8 80
D 1 21 5 16
D 1 22 4 10
D 1 23 6 28
D 1 24 3 6
D 1 25 9 0
D 1 26 5 16
D 1 27 8 80
D 1 28 7 50
D 1 29 4 10
D 1 30 7 50
D 1 31 2 3
D 1 32 8 80
D 1 33 9 0
D 1 34 9 0
D 1 35 3 6
D 1 36 1 0
D 1 37 4 10
D 1 38 1 0
D 1 39 1 0
D 1 40 6 28
D 1 41 5 16
D 1 42 2 3
D 1 43 2 3
D 1 44 9 0
D 1 45 7 50
 

Color codes of rebars used to mark treatments in E001

Experiment Color Treatment
E001 White A
E001 Brown B
E001 Silver C
E001 Black D
E001 Yellow E
E001 Red F
E001 Green G
E001 Blue H
E001 None I
 

abue001 - Field C Microplot Arthropod Sweepnet Sampling

Field C Microplot Arthropod Sweepnet Sampling

This dataset was collected from Field C ?Microplots?. Field C was abandoned from agriculture in 1935. See methods for E001 ?Microplots? for information on plot layout, nutrient treatments, fencing and other methods or irregularities. Arthropods were sampled on 31/Aug/1995, 28/June/1996 and 30/July/1996 by taking 25 sweeps/plot with a standard 15-inch-diameter light muslin net. Each sweep consisted of a rapid horizontal swing of the net about 2 meters long. After 25 sweeps, net contents were transferred to 4-liter plastic bags and frozen. Samples were later thawed, dried and all arthropods were removed under a Bausch and Lomb x10 microscope, identified to species or morphospecies and counted. Counts were exact for all insects except aphids. When aphid counts were high, numbers were approximated to the nearest 10. *Note about comparing experiments: morphological notes may not indicate the same species/group in different experiments. Voucher specimens were stored at Cedar Creek ESR, and are now either at the University of Minnesota Insect Collection on the Saint Paul Campus or in the teaching collection at Cedar Creek.

Field C Microplot Arthropod Sweepnet Sampling: Data Preparation

Data was prepared by Nick Haddad and John Haarstad. abue001 dataset updates formatting, corrects dates from a previous version and was prepared by Colleen Satyshur with help from N. Haddad, Haddad confirmed date changes reflected in this file.

lpe001 - Percent light penetration

Light Penetration

Readings were taken .5m from the front and back of each plot. The distance from the left or right edge varied from year to year. If light readings were taken before the vegetation was sampled that year, the light readings were taken in the location of the clip strip. If light readings were taken after the vegetation had been clipped, the location of the light readings was moved to one side, or the other, of the clip strip so the bare spot would not affect the readings. Usually, a set of readings were taken from the front of the plot and a second set was taken from the back of the plot. The date, time, field, plot, side (left or right), front or back, distance from the side of the plot, range value (before 1988) and the display reading were all recorded for each measurement.

If there was a gopher mound where the light readings should be taken, the sensor was moved in from the edge of the plot until it is no longer over a gopher mound. This was then recorded on the data sheet.

Light Penetration Instrumentation

From 1982 to 1988, light meter readings were taken using a Li-Cor, Inc. Integrating Quantum/Radiometer/Photometer, model LI-188B. Two people were needed to take light readings with this system. One would hold the control box and record data and the other would hold the light sensor. The batteries would be checked before starting each session. If the batteries were OK, they would proceed to take readings. The sensor was connected to the control box by a relatively short cord, so the two people taking readings were required to stay close together. When taking readings, it was necessary to get a range value for each light value entered. If the integrating time of 1 second was not sufficient, it was increased to 10 seconds. This was also recorded.

In 1989, two new light meters were acquired. These are SF Sunfleck Ceptometers, model SF-40 (40cm probe). They were purchased from Decagon Devices, Inc., P.O. Box 835, Pullman, WA 99163. One person can easily handle a ceptometer alone. This makes is possible for three people to get the readings done more quickly and easily. One person records data while the other two take readings from the plots simultaneously. No range values are needed. To take readings a person needs to select function #1 (PAR readings), position the probe (see below) and press ``A' (read value). More than one reading can be taken and then averaged by pressing a certain sequence of letters (A, A, B, B, A).

Measurements are taken within a 4 hour period, 2 hours on either side of solar noon. (Solar noon is half way between sunrise and sunset; it is not 1200 hours). Solar noon is at 1315 hours, Central Daylight Time. Samples are taken between 1115 hours and 1515 hours. Measurements are not taken when the plot being sampled is shaded. Light readings are done when the sky is clear, whenever possible. If a cloud passes over the plot being sampled, assistants wait for the cloud to pass before taking the readings. If the sky is mostly cloudy, light meter readings are not taken.

Two measurements are taken in each plot. Each measurement consists of one reading above the vegetation and a second reading at ground level. Both values are taken to get the percent of sunlight above the vegetation that reaches ground level. In taking the above vegetation reading, the sensor must be kept level, held high above all vegetation, kept out of the shade (of plants and people) and it must be clean. When taking the below vegetation reading, at ground level, the sensor must be kept level, out of the soil and out of the shade created by people.

In 1991, light meter readings were only taken in E026 and E055. Light profiles were taken using an A-shaped frame made of aluminum. Wires were strung across the frame at 10cm intervals. The frame was placed over the subplot being metered. A reading was taken over the top of the frame, and then at each 10cm level, by placing the light meter across the wires, starting at 90cm above the ground. Readings were taken every 10cm down the frame and again at ground level.
Light Data Transformations:
Light readings are transformed to obtain percent light penetration which represents the percent of light above the vegetation that reaches the ground surface. In cases where the experiment involves shading, another variable is computed to reflect the percent of sun light that reaches above the canopy. This variable is called light available. In the case of absence of artificial shades, the latter is set to 1.

percent light penetration = ( Light below canopy / Light above canopy ).

percent light available = ( Light below shade / Light above shade ).

mse001 - Small mammal abundance

Animal Sampling Methods

Small mammals, including mice, voles and pocket gophers, are trapped out of E001 in fields A, B, C, and D. The fence around each of these fields is designed to keep these small mammals out, but some get in regardless. The mice and voles are trapped out of the fields by using Victor snap traps baited with a mixture of peanut butter and oatmeal. Between 50 and 75 traps are set in each field (only 25 in D). This is most often done in the spring and fall. The traps are checked the day after they are set. Trap victims are identified and the numbers of each are recorded. The bodies are disposed of outside of the fields. In the middle of the summer, victims are quickly eaten and often all that is left behind are bones. These are not identified, but counted as skeletons or skulls.

The pocket gophers do more damage, but they are more difficult to trap. Underground tunnels are located by poking a rebar into the ground surrounding a fresh gopher mound. When a tunnel is found, a hole is dug down to it and traps are set in place. Two or three traps may be set in a tunnel system if the hole is dug into a branching tunnel. Traps used are DK-1 Gopher and Mole Traps made by P-W Mfg. Co., 610 High Street, Henryetta, OK 74437 (918) 652-4981. Sometimes a piece of raw potato is used as bait. The hole is then plugged and covered so no light or air gets into the tunnel system. This would make the gopher suspect that something was wrong and it would backfill the tunnel, burying the traps. Traps are checked every second or third day in the summer, and once or twice a week in the spring and fall. Once a gopher is trapped out of a tunnel system, poison pellets are put down the tunnel in case there is a second gopher in the sutem or if another one moves in soon. Cyanide gas and sulphur gas have also been used to kill gophers, but there is no direct evidence of gopher death due to these gases. Trapping seems to be the most effective way to get rid of them. After the gophers are trapped out, the mounds are removed from the plots, and any buried and flattened vegetation is unburied and unflattened. This is done as soon as possible to keep the plants from dying. The locations of gopher mounds and trapped gophers are recorded.

Field Operations: Mammal Trapping

Small mammals are trapped as often as possible to keep the resident population low. Pocket gophers are trapped out of the fields as soon as they appear. Gopher mounds are then removed and vegetation is unburied.

ple001 - Plant aboveground biomass data

Above ground sampling

Above ground sampling: Aboveground vegetation is sampled annually. Sampling is done the same way in each of the four fields, A, B, C, and D. Field A is sampled first, usually in early July. Field B is sampled second, usually in late July or early August. Field C is sampled third, usually in mid-August. Field D is sampled last, usually in late August. These sampling times were chosen to correspond with the usual time of peak biomass in each of the fields. Each year, the sample strip is located in a different place. Documentation on where the strips are located for each year can be found in the sampling maps. A 10cm x 3m strip of vegetation is clipped out of each plot. Aboveground vegetation is collected in narrow strips to limit the effect of the sampling. Benches are used to avoid trampling the surrounding area. A 3m long fiberglass pole is placed along the ground next to the appropriate site of the present year's sample strip. This is used as a guide to keep the 3m long sample strip straight. Vegetation is cut using a Sears/Craftsman Extra Heavy Duty Cordless Electric Grass Shears, model # 240.79672. These clippers have blades which are 10cm wide, making it easy to clip a strip of that width. The clippers are powered by 6-volt motorcycle batteries. All vegetation that is rooted in the 10cm wide strip is cut 1-2cm from the soil surface. The vegetation and litter that was in the strip is collected. Care is taken to clip and collect only that material which is actually in the 10cm wide strip, not entire plants that may lay across the strip. If there is a gopher mound in the plot where the clip strip is, the strip is moved in towards the middle of the plot until it is no longer over a gopher mound. The new position of the clip strip is then recorded. Below ground sampling: Root samples are taken from treatment I plots annually. The sample is obtained using a two inch diameter corer. Three core samples of depth 0-30cm are taken from the area that has been clipped within a few days after clipping. The roots and associated crowns are extracted from the sample by washing with water above a screen. Any extraneous non-root material is removed. The cleaned roots are dried and weighted. In 1994 samples were taken from all plots in the experiment. Three cores were taken from each plot using the two inch diameter corer and combined into one sample. Cores were taken to a depth of 15cm.

Listing of location of aboveground vegetation sampling in E001 Field A

Year Clipped Area
1982 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1982 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1983 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1984 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1985 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1986 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1987 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1988 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1989 Clipped 0.35 to 0.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1990 Clipped 3.55 to 3.65m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1991 Clipped 0.6 to 0.7m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1992 Clipped 3.3 to 3.4m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1993 Clipped 3.3 to 3.4m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1994 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1995 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1996 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1997 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1998 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1999 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2000 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2001 Clipped 1.35 to 1.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2002 Clipped 2.55 to 2.65m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2003 Clipped 1.80 to 1.90m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2004 Clipped 1.90 to 1.80m from right, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom


Sampling Discrepancies in E001 Field A
Year Sampling Discrepancy
1982 none
1983 none
1984 Plot 9 clipped at 3.15-3.25m from left side, Plot 42 clipped at 3.25-3.35m from left side, Plot 34 clipped at 3.30-3.40m from left side
1985 none
1986 none
1987 Plot 20 reclipped at 3.38-3.48m from left side due to lost Carex sample
1988 Plot 20 reclipped at 3.55-3.65m from left side, Plot 48 clipped at 0.35-0.45m from left side
1989 Plot 31 reclipped at 3.75-3.85m from left side due to 1/2 of sample lost
1990 none
1991 none
1992 none
1993 Plot 40 clipped at 3.20-3.30m from left side to avoid old gopher mound
1994 Plot 1 clipped at 0.45-0.55m from left to avoid old clip strip, Plot 9 clipped at 0.45-0.55m from left side to avoid old slip strip
1995 none
1996 none
1997 none
1998 none
1999 Plot 48 clipped 0.90-1.00m from left to avoid gopher mound
2000 Plots 5, 24, 33, 34, 46, 47, 48, 51 clipped 3.55-3.65m from left
2001 Plot 5 clipped 2.55-2.65m from left to avoid stump, Plot 11 clipped 2.55-2.65m from left to avoid gopher mound, Plot 24 clipped 2.55-2.65m from left to avoid tump, Plot 29 clipped 2.55-2.65m from left to avoid nest of ground bees
2002 Plots 5, 11, 24, 29 clipped 1.80-1.90m from left
2003 none
2004 Plot 14, 29, 42 clipped at 1.60-1.50m from right

Listing of location of aboveground vegetation sampling in E001 Field B

Year Clipped Area
1982 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1982 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1983 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1984 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1985 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1986 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1987 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1988 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1989 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1990 Clipped 3.55 to 3.65m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1991 Clipped 0.35 to 0.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1992 Clipped 3.3 to 3.4m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1993 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1994 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1995 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1996 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1997 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1998 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1999 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2000 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2001 Clipped 1.35 to 1.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2002 Clipped 2.55 to 2.65m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2003 Clipped 1.80 to 1.90m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2004 Clipped 1.90 to 1.80m from right, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom

Sampling Discrepancies in E001 Field B
Year Sampling Discrepancy
1982 none
1983 none
1984 none
1985 none
1986 none
1987 Plot 31 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side, Plot 34 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side, Plot 36 clipped at 100-110 from left side, B-1-38 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side
1988 Plot 15 reclipped at 3.55-3.65m from left side, Plot 16 reclipped at 3.55-3.65m from left side. These two plots were sorted together initially, so they needed to be resampled.
1989 none
1990 none
1991 Plot 53 clipped at 3.10-3.20cm from left side due to wasp nest in initial clip strip.
1992 none
1993 none
1994 Plot 37 clipped at 3.10-3.20cm from right to avoid a wasp nest
1995 none
1996 none
1997 none
1998 none
1999 none
2000 Plots 7, 8, 9, 16 clipped 3.40-3.50m from left
2001 none
2002 Plots 7, 16, 17 clipped 1.80-1.90m from left due to clip strips moved previous year
2003 Plots 7, 16 clipped 1.05-1.15m from left due gopher mounds
2004 Plots 16, 29 clipped 1.60-1.50m from right

Listing of location of aboveground vegetation sampling in E001 Field C

Year Clipped Area
1982 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1982 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1983 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1984 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1985 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1986 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1987 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1988 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1989 Clipped 0.35 to 0.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1990 Clipped 3.55 to 3.65m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1991 Clipped 0.6 to 0.7m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1992 Clipped 3.3 to 3.4m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1993 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1994 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1995 Clipped 3.4 to 3.5m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1996 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1997 Clipped 3.15 to 3.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1998 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1999 Clipped 3 to 3.1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2000 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2001 Clipped 1.35 to 1.45m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2002 Clipped 3.65 to 3.75m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2003 Clipped 1.80 to 1.90m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2004 Clipped 1.90 to 1.80m from right, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2005 Clipped 1.20 to 1.30m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2006 Clipped 1.60 to 1.50m from right, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom

Sampling Discrepancies in E001 Field C
Year Sampling Discrepancy
1982 none
1983 Plot 15 clipped at 0.60-0.70m from left side to avoid a gopher mound
1984 Plot 31 to Plot 49 clipped at 0.50-0.60m from left side
1985 none
1986 Plot 43 clipped at 0.75-0.85m from left side, Plot 45 clipped at 0.75-0.85m from left side, Plot 46 clipped at 0.75-0.85m from left side
1987 none
1988 Plot 12 clipped at 3.55-3.65cm from left side
1989 none
1990 none
1991 none
1992 none
1993 none
1994 none
1995 none
1996 none
1997 none
1998 none
1999 none
2000 none
2001 Plot 50 clipped 2.55-2.65m from left due to gopher disturbance
2002 none
2003 none
2004 none
2005 Plots 34 clipped at 0.20-0.10m from right side
2006 none

Listing of location of aboveground vegetation sampling in E001 Field D

Year Clipped Area
1982 Clipped 0.25 to 0.35m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1983 Clipped 1.15 to 1.25m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1984 Clipped 1.05 to 1.15m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1985 Clipped 0.75 to 0.85m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1986 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1987 Clipped 0.37 to 0.47m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1988 Clipped 1.03 to 1.13m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1989 Clipped 0.6 to 0.7m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1990 Clipped 0.8 to 0.9m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1991 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1992 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 0.4 to 0.5m from bottom
1992 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 3.6 to 3.7m from bottom
1993 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 0.7 to 0.8m from bottom
1993 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 3.3 to 3.4m from bottom
1994 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 1 to 1.1m from bottom
1994 Clipped 0 to 1.5m from left, 3 to 3.1m from bottom June
1995 Clipped 0.2 to 0.3m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom June
1995 Clipped 1.2 to 1.3m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom Aug
1996 Clipped 0.7 to 0.8m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1997 Clipped 0.7 to 0.8m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1998 Clipped 0.3 to 0.4m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
1999 Clipped 1.1 to 1.2m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2000 Clipped 0.6 to 0.7m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2001 Clipped 0.9 to 1m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2002 Clipped 0.5 to 0.6m from left, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom
2004 Clipped 0.30 to 0.20 from right, 0.5 to 3.5m from bottom

Sampling Discrepancies in E001 Field D
Year Sampling Discrepancy
1982 none
1983 none
1984 none
1985 none
1986 Plot 21 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side, Plot 22 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side, Plot 24 clipped at 1.00-1.10m from left side, These plots were clipped in a different place due to a misunderstanding about the clip strip placement.
1987 Plot 1 clipped at 0.27-0.37m from left side, Plot 2 clipped at 0.27-0.37m from left side, Plot 3 clipped at 0.27-0.37m from left side. These three plots were clipped in a different place due to a misunderstanding about the clip strip placement. Plot 20 reclipped at 0.27-0.37m from left side.
1988 Plot 7 clipped at 1.13-1.23m from left side
1989 Plot 2 reclipped at 1.25-1.35cm from left side, Plot 3 reclipped at 1.25-1.35cm from left side. These two plots were sorted together initially, and needed to be resampled.
1990 none
1991 none
1992 Plot 43 reclipped at 0.30-0.40m from front and back (sorted with Plot 45), Plot 45 reclipped at 0.30-0.40m from front and back (sorted with Plot 43)
1993 none
1994 Plot 2 clipped at 0.90-1.00cm from front to avoid a gopher mound
1995 none
1996 none
1997 none
1998 none
1999 none
2000 none
2001 none
2002 none
2004 Gopher Mound in plot 29

rbe001 - Root biomass data

Above ground sampling

Above ground sampling: Aboveground vegetation is sampled annually. Sampling is done the same way in each of the four fields, A, B, C, and D. Field A is sampled first, usually in early July. Field B is sampled second, usually in late July or early August. Field C is sampled third, usually in mid-August. Field D is sampled last, usually in late August. These sampling times were chosen to correspond with the usual time of peak biomass in each of the fields. Each year, the sample strip is located in a different place. Documentation on where the strips are located for each year can be found in the sampling maps. A 10cm x 3m strip of vegetation is clipped out of each plot. Aboveground vegetation is collected in narrow strips to limit the effect of the sampling. Benches are used to avoid trampling the surrounding area. A 3m long fiberglass pole is placed along the ground next to the appropriate site of the present year's sample strip. This is used as a guide to keep the 3m long sample strip straight. Vegetation is cut using a Sears/Craftsman Extra Heavy Duty Cordless Electric Grass Shears, model # 240.79672. These clippers have blades which are 10cm wide, making it easy to clip a strip of that width. The clippers are powered by 6-volt motorcycle batteries. All vegetation that is rooted in the 10cm wide strip is cut 1-2cm from the soil surface. The vegetation and litter that was in the strip is collected. Care is taken to clip and collect only that material which is actually in the 10cm wide strip, not entire plants that may lay across the strip. If there is a gopher mound in the plot where the clip strip is, the strip is moved in towards the middle of the plot until it is no longer over a gopher mound. The new position of the clip strip is then recorded. Below ground sampling: Root samples are taken from treatment I plots annually. The sample is obtained using a two inch diameter corer. Three core samples of depth 0-30cm are taken from the area that has been clipped within a few days after clipping. The roots and associated crowns are extracted from the sample by washing with water above a screen. Any extraneous non-root material is removed. The cleaned roots are dried and weighted. In 1994 samples were taken from all plots in the experiment. Three cores were taken from each plot using the two inch diameter corer and combined into one sample. Cores were taken to a depth of 15cm.