Cedar Creek Natural History Area: Literature   Up   Home


Citation. Reich, P.B.; Tjoelker, M.G.; Machado, J.L.; Oleksyn, J. 2007. Biological Scaling: Does the Exception Prove the Rule?. Nature 445:E9-E11. 

Abstract. Enquist et al.1 raise several points that they claim cast doubt on our findings and interpretation2 regarding whole-plant relations of respiration, R, with plant mass, M, and total plant nitrogen content, N. We agree with Enquist et al. that R does not scale isometrically with M across all plants. However, their assertion that we claim that isometric scaling (R M , with = 1) is universal in plants of all sizes is incorrect — in fact, we conclude the opposite2, noting that there is isometric scaling within individual experiments, non-isometric scaling of respiration versus mass across all data pooled, and no common relation across all data2.

For reprints or technical issues, please correspond with the author of the paper. For comments on the format or contents of the web site, please contact webmaster@cedarcreek.umn.edu